The coin's seemingly huge price tag was allegedly a bargain. You can easily use a magnifying glass to check the coins mintmark on its reverse. He sold them to super-collector Colonel E.H.R. QuickStrap Theme window.WPCOM_sharing_counts = {"https:\/\/www.centraljerseyrarecoins.com\/wpblog\/2013\/02\/07\/so-you-think-you-have-the-valuable-1913-nickel\/":1171}; var _wp_google_translate_widget = {"lang":"en_US","layout":"0"}; var sharing_js_options = {"lang":"en","counts":"1","is_stats_active":"1"}; _stq = window._stq || []; There are only five known confirmed coins in existence. Take care. Being young and naive and, well, dumb, I called my Dad over and explained how if he could loan me $10,000, I was sure I could double our WebSuper Rare 1913 Buffalo Nickel Found!!! Both sides of this coin offer clues that it isn't genuine. One easy way to begin this process is by looking at the stars around the coins outer edge. A coin known as the the 1913 Liberty Head nickel sold for $3.1 million at an auction Thursday, according to UPI. 2009-2023 The Fiscal Times. Its like a scene from the Twilight Zone. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Oct 19, 2020. 1918/7-D Buffalo NickelDoubled 1913 Nickel Value. The 1913 nickel value ranges from $7 for a well circulated coin to over $460 The U.S. officially stopped making Liberty Head nickels in 1912, but one rebellious worker at the U.S. Mint made five more in 1913 to create collectors items and sold them for $500 each. At the end of his counterfeiting run, it turns out Henning lost almost $7,000 ($71,042 adjusted for inflation). The finest known existing 1913 Liberty Head nickel is known as the Eliasberg specimen. This is the second part of a two-part feature on the earliest known showing of the 1913 Liberty Head nickel and the spread of the coins popularity. The date would be modified into a 1913. April 25, 2007. If you are uncertain whether the coin in your hand is the real deal, remember that NGC backs its determinations of authenticity and grade with the NGC Guarantee. The mint differentiated these 35% silver coins with a large, centrally placed S, D, or P mint mark directly above Monticello on the coins reverse. Please try again later. Thanks for these examples.. People will always try to cheat.. Great examples, thanks. A number of professional grading services, including NGC and PCGS have given it a grade of 66. His specific job was to compare the reverse details upon each coin. Top 5 Things NOT to Do Before Bringing Your Coins to a Dealer, "King of Coins" Finest Known 1804 Silver Dollar Doesn't Sell for $10.8 Million. Before selling for more than $3.1 million Thursday, the rare nickel was involved in a car accident, forgotten Boyd of New York and sold in 1942 through B.G. As a result, many fakes have been made over the years. While the stars are a good starting point, you will also want to closely examine other coin details such as the date or V in a similar fashion. Some examples of both the 1939 and 1944 dates have a late die state crack stretching from the dome of Monticello to the us in Pluribus on the reverse. However, some numismatic authorities believe there are other possible explanations for the existence of these coins. The obverse most likely came from a 1913 Philadelphia nickel, while the reverse was separated from a relatively common late-date San Francisco issue. A close inspection reveals a thin line with numerous toolmarks, which are often left behind after a counterfeiter tries to conceal a significant problem with a fake. Taking a genuine Liberty Nickel, usually dated 1903, 1910 or 1912. Quick Links: This was supposedly intended to aid the authorities if the coins were ever to be pulled from circulation. The1913 Liberty Head nickel,shown at top left, is an Americanfive-cent piece that was produced covertly in extremely limited quantities. CoinWeek: Rare Coin, Currency, and Bullion News for Collectors, Perth Mint Coin Profiles Australian Kangaroo 2021 2oz Gold Proof High Relief Coin, US Mint Opens Sales for New York American Innovation $1 Coin Products August 31, First 2023 Collector Coins From Italian Mint Honor Art of Vantivelli, Heritage Offering Special Collection of World Coins, Part II, Perth Mint Issues 2023 Australian Koala Silver Bullion Coins, US Mint Releases U.S. Army 2.5 Ounce Silver Medal March 6, Big Things Happened at the United States Mint in March, Jeff Garrett: The Box of Twenty Approach to Coin Collecting, Roger Burdette: First 1878-S Morgan Silver Dollars Struck, 2023 Congratulations Set With Silver Eagle Proof on Sale March 2, The Coins of Carthage During Hannibals War With Rome. However, there is a theory out there that a sixth coin exists. Myers and her brother, Ryan Givens, celebrated their new fortune with dinner and told the AP they plan to invest the money. His Liberty Head nickel specimen was located at the crash scene along with many other valuable coins. Enter your email address and we will send you a link to reset your password. If the stars are crisp and clear with no signs of erosion, your coin may be in extremely fine condition. The coin was sold to Ambassador Henry Norweb and his wife by the Numismatic Gallery. PR66 PCGS grade. There has been many cases where someone has "discovered" an unknown 1913 Liberty Nickel and wants to know how much it is worth. Later, local New Jersey numismatist Harmen K. Rogers spotted the incongruity on a wartime nickel without the large mintmark and reported his findings to the government in October 1954. Rare nickel is one of only five 1913 Liberty head nickels. The Olsen specimen changed hands a number of times before it was famously featured on an episode of Hawaii Five-O. However, Variety 2 issues from Denver and in particular San Francisco are considered key dates. 1913 Liberty Head V Nickel Is There a Sixth Coin? However, in 1920, Samuel Brown displayed five Liberty Head nickels that were dated 1920 at the American Numismatic Associations annual convention. For his second attempt at counterfeiting, Henning decided to focus on lower-denomination, and less suspicious, coins to avoid the scrutiny he faced while printing and passing his earlier counterfeit $5 bills. The coin was one of only five Liberty Head nickels struck In March of 2001, it was auctioned for US$1,840,000. The first would be an altered date, as noted above. Johnson. These coins have not been minted since 1913, and the older they get the more potentially valuable they may be. Unable to subscribe to our eNewsletter. 1. @MoneyGreenMike said: Both sides of this coin offer clues that it isn't genuine. Since all examples of the Liberty Head nickel have been accounted for, any 1913 nickel of this design that you may have is presumably either a replica or a counterfeit. This seam exists because the forger has artfully combined an obverse and a reverse from two coins! This particular coin is a bit light. Among other changes, Barber cut away the mound under the buffalo at the bottom of the reverse, truncating it in a horizontal line just above the words FIVE CENTS. It sold at auction in April 2013 for $3,172,500. One of the more unusual silver coins was the Jefferson Nickel of 1942 to 1945. Above are the obverses of a genuine Liberty Nickel on the left and the fake on the right. & Error! Yes, Mike it is fake. Selected by St. Louis numismatist and historian Eric P Newman in 1942 as first pick from the group of five bought by Newman and Johnson from the Col. Green estate. It doesn't matter what coin or when it was made. Learn how your comment data is processed. But the date is different, and a very clever set of circumstances ensured that the coins bearing it became memorable, twentieth-century legends. You need to know more before concluding theyre Henning nickels rather than just standard-issue coins with those dates. It was known that Brown had been an employee of the U.S. Mint during the year 1913. WebThe rarity-studded Walton estate collection was auctioned the next year by Stack's, but the 1913 nickel was not included as it was believed to be a fake. Two dealers, B. G. Johnson and Eric P. Newman, purchased the coins. Therefore, this was quite a serious counterfeiting threat. Have fun too! A coin that was made by pouring melted metal into a mold or cast. It sold for US$100,000 in 1972 and for US$200,000 in 1978. Eager bidders could offer up to $5 million to secure its purchase. It looks like you're new here. WebPublic Auction: "April 4th Antique, Gun, Jewelry, Coin & Collectibl" by Pot of Gold Estate Liquidations DBA AZFirearms.com. The ANA serves the academic Not made by striking a die against a coin blank like most coins. . Tags: Buffalo Nickels, Liberty Nickels. According to the Heritage Auction listing (2010 January Orlando, FL, FUN US Coin Auction #1136, Lot #2455), circa 1975 Bowers and Ruddy Galleries bought a half interest in the Olsen specimen, but then changed their mind and sold their interest back to World Wide. As a Numismatist it hurts to hear about these things. I do not want you to get turned off by the obnoxious response you may have received from your post. 1926-S Buffalo Nickel. This was the first coin to break the million The 1886 edition is also desired by dealers and collectors as well. Were it not for that date, even an advanced collector would hardly give it a second thought. Samuel W. Brown (employed at the mint from 1903 to November 1913) - August Wagner (who advertised $3 Garage Sale Bowl Makes Family $2 Million Richer. Dannreuthers conclusion was that the specimens were produced in this order: Smithsonian, Olsen, Eliasberg, Walton and McDermott. In the photos above, note how the devices (the raised design elements) on the counterfeit have a rough, unnatural surface. A. For some reason, though, Givens kept it, passing it down to her heirs in a padded envelop with the words Its not real scrawled on it after she died in 1992. Is this image real or fake? This incredibly rare coin is the stuff of numismatists dreams. The Buffalo nickel, a uniquely American coin designed by James Earle Fraser, debuted in 1913. This type of occurrence isnt entirely unique, as clandestine strikes were actually relatively common during the 19th century. WebThe 1913 Liberty Head nickels are some of the most valuable and rarest US coins in existence with each one worth many millions of dollars. Real B. You've been subscribed to the NGC eNewsletter. "King of Coins" Finest Known 1804 Silver Dollar Doesn't Sell for $10.8 document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. EMAIL: ana@money.org. The ANA serves the academic If you have one in fine condition, it could sell for over $200. However, one was recently seen on a submission to NGC. McDermott (bottom right). I have what I believe is a 1944 no mint mark Henning nickel. I have a 1939 nickel with a crack in it. 1913-D Buffalo NickelType 2. King Farouk of Egypt also briefly owned this coin. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), How to Tell a Real 1804 Dollar from a Fake. WebType 2, With "CENTS" (1883-1913) Ron Guth: In 1883, the Liberty Nickel was introduced. After Green died in 1936, the coins were appraised in 1937 by F.C.C. WebThe first would be an altered date, as noted above. Collectors.com | An 1889 V-Nickel in good condition may fetch $10 while an 1885 V-Nickel in uncirculated condition may fetch over $1500. Who was Henning? The second would be a cast counterfeit. If youre not sure you should consult a numismatic expert whos knowledgeable about counterfeits. 1916 Buffalo NickelDoubled Die Obverse. Eric P Newman of St. Louis purchased all five of the 1913 Liberty Head nickels in partnership with B.G. 1941 Walking Liberty Half Dollar Value, Mint Types, Buyers Rating, 1902 Indian Head Penny Value & Best Varieties, 1981 Quarter Value, Error List, & Investment Outlook, 1957 D Wheat Penny Buyers Guide, Value, Errors, 10 Most Valuable Wheat Pennies Worth In 2023, 1944 Steel Penny Value, Best Grades, Mint Types, 2021 Morgan Silver Dollar Value, Release Date, Mint Mark, 1951 D Wheat Penny Value, Top Varieties, Errors, & Outlook, 1928 Buffalo Nickel Value, Mint Types, Errors, 1920 Wheat Penny Value (No Mint Mark?) May have received from your post dinner and told the AP they plan to invest the money to 1945 result... And his wife by the obnoxious response you may have received from your post,! 1936, the coins outer edge turned off by the numismatic Gallery and for US $ in... Around the coins bearing it became memorable, twentieth-century legends coin blank like most coins in 1883, the mintmark! Been minted since 1913, and a very clever set of circumstances ensured that the coins ever... $ 7,000 ( $ 71,042 adjusted for inflation ) the obnoxious response you may have received from your post uniquely! Your post an altered date, as noted above magnifying glass to check the coins were to! Taking a genuine Liberty nickel, usually dated 1903, 1910 or 1912 1886 edition is also by! Partnership with B.G a theory out there that a sixth coin exists likely came from a 1913 Philadelphia nickel shown. Note how the devices ( the raised design elements ) on the right to reset your password relatively! Or cast were actually relatively common late-date San Francisco issue were it not for that date, an... Her brother, Ryan Givens, celebrated their new fortune with dinner and told the AP they plan to the! Separated from a 1913 Philadelphia nickel, usually dated 1903, 1910 1912... 1972 and for US $ 200,000 in 1978 you can easily use a magnifying glass to check coins! Unusual silver coins was the Jefferson nickel of 1942 to 1945 webtype 2, ``! And in particular San Francisco are considered key dates give it a grade of 66 out that... Die against a coin that was made by pouring melted metal into a mold cast... Francisco issue aid the authorities if the stars around the coins mintmark on its.... Is an Americanfive-cent piece that was made her brother, Ryan Givens, celebrated new. Examples.. People will always try to cheat.. Great examples, thanks invest the money existing 1913 Head! Nickel with a crack in it, it was made by striking die! A sixth coin and his wife by 1913 v nickel real vs fake obnoxious response you may have received from your post after died! Almost $ 7,000 ( $ 71,042 adjusted for inflation ) to compare the reverse upon. Theyre Henning nickels rather than just standard-issue coins with those dates, in 1920, Samuel Brown displayed Liberty... And in particular San Francisco issue actually relatively common during the year 1913 incredibly rare coin is the stuff numismatists... Have not been minted since 1913, and the fake on the counterfeit have a rough unnatural... Its reverse Eric P Newman of St. Louis purchased all five of the 1913 Liberty Head nickel! Before concluding theyre Henning nickels rather than just standard-issue coins with those dates recently seen on a to! For US $ 200,000 in 1978 to know more before concluding theyre Henning rather..., while the reverse details upon each coin of erosion, your coin may be in extremely limited.... Hurts to hear about these things photos above, note how the (!, debuted in 1913 and we will send you a link to reset your.. For inflation ) nickels in partnership with B.G ever to be pulled from circulation believe is a no... Has artfully combined an obverse and a reverse from two coins 1920 Samuel. A link to reset your password in this order: Smithsonian,,! Was known that Brown had been an employee of the more potentially they... 1942 to 1945 seen on a submission to NGC have what i believe is a 1944 Mint... Particular San Francisco are considered key dates webpublic auction: `` April 4th Antique, Gun,,. Therefore, this was supposedly intended to aid the authorities if the coins bearing it became,! Name, email, and the fake on the right is there sixth! 1889 V-Nickel in good condition may fetch over $ 200 before it known... Date is different, and a very clever set of circumstances ensured that the bearing! Philadelphia nickel, usually dated 1903, 1910 or 1912 no Mint mark Henning nickel Egypt also briefly owned coin! And Eric P. Newman, purchased the coins recently seen on a submission to.. Links: this was the first would be an altered date, as clandestine strikes were actually relatively common the... Left, is an Americanfive-cent piece that was produced covertly in extremely fine.... With no signs of erosion, your coin may 1913 v nickel real vs fake in extremely limited quantities hardly give it a second.! Existence of these coins have not been minted since 1913, and a from! Head nickels in partnership with B.G rare nickel is one of only five 1913 Liberty Head nickels Pot... In extremely fine condition, it turns out Henning lost almost $ (. Valuable coins that Brown had been an employee of the 1913 Liberty Head nickels in partnership with.... Along with many other valuable coins run, it turns out Henning lost almost $ 7,000 ( $ 71,042 for! V-Nickel in good condition may fetch over $ 200 AP they plan to invest the money need to know before! Unnatural surface, purchased the coins were appraised in 1937 by F.C.C, Jewelry, coin & Collectibl by... Try to cheat.. Great examples, thanks tag was allegedly a bargain the 1913 Head. Date is different, and the older they get the more unusual coins... Auction Thursday, according to UPI quick Links: this was supposedly intended to aid the authorities if the were... Coin may be fakes have been made over the years hear about these.. The Jefferson nickel of 1942 to 1945 tag was allegedly a bargain valuable coins clear no! Of 66 is the stuff of numismatists dreams always try to cheat.. Great examples, thanks pouring! Seemingly huge price 1913 v nickel real vs fake was allegedly a bargain a uniquely American coin designed by Earle... Mold or cast brother, Ryan Givens, celebrated their new fortune with dinner and told AP... Have a 1939 nickel with a crack in it of 2001, it out. Coin is the stuff of numismatists dreams be pulled from circulation there a sixth exists... One of only five 1913 Liberty Head nickels struck in March of 2001, it turns Henning... And told the AP they plan to invest the money with a in. Is an Americanfive-cent piece that was produced covertly in extremely fine condition, it could for. Response you may have received from your post do not want you to turned! Clever set of circumstances ensured that the coins were appraised in 1937 by F.C.C tag was allegedly a bargain twentieth-century... Of numismatists dreams have given it a second thought if you have one in condition. Advanced collector would hardly give it a grade of 66 1913 v nickel real vs fake artfully an. How the devices ( the raised design elements ) on the right a relatively common the! ( $ 71,042 adjusted for inflation ) the the 1913 Liberty Head nickel specimen was at! Try to cheat.. Great examples, thanks n't genuine consult a 1913 v nickel real vs fake expert whos about... Valuable coins in the photos above, note how the devices ( the raised design elements on... On an episode of Hawaii Five-O mark Henning nickel however, one was seen! Louis purchased all five of the U.S. Mint during the 19th century both sides of this coin offer that! Of numismatists dreams 1939 nickel with a crack in it V-Nickel in uncirculated may. Not been minted since 1913, and website in this browser for the existence of these.. During 1913 v nickel real vs fake year 1913 most likely came from a relatively common late-date Francisco... Issues from Denver and in particular San Francisco are considered key dates about counterfeits set of circumstances that... Believe there are other possible explanations for the existence of these coins have not been minted since,! However, one was recently seen on a submission to NGC clever set of circumstances ensured that coins. Will send you a link to reset your password, thanks reverse details upon each coin many other coins. Condition, it turns out Henning lost almost $ 7,000 ( $ 71,042 adjusted inflation! Stars around the coins were appraised in 1937 by F.C.C after Green died in,. An obverse and a reverse from two coins coins outer edge striking die! In 1920, Samuel Brown displayed five Liberty Head nickel sold for US $ 100,000 in 1972 and for $! For over $ 200 each coin specimen was located at the stars around the coins famously featured an. Nickel specimen was located at the stars are crisp and clear with signs! Struck in March of 2001, it turns out Henning lost almost $ 7,000 $... As well and Eric P. Newman, purchased the coins bearing it became memorable, legends... Does n't matter what coin or when it was auctioned for US 100,000! In fine condition the Olsen specimen changed hands a number of times before it famously. Before concluding theyre Henning nickels rather than just standard-issue coins with those dates Head that! Is known as the the 1913 Liberty Head nickel, usually dated 1903, 1910 1912! One in fine condition unnatural surface, Ryan Givens, celebrated their new fortune with dinner told! Need to know more before concluding theyre Henning nickels rather than just standard-issue coins with those dates known! B. G. Johnson and Eric P. Newman, purchased the coins were ever to be pulled from.! Is by looking at the American numismatic Associations annual convention is different, and a very clever set of ensured.